Emails: bus staff didn't properly strap in 7-year-old who died on Cincinnati school bus
File photo: City of Newport BeachEmails released this week show that hours after 7-year-old Ngone Talla died aboard a Cincinnati school bus, the district superintendent told the school board the driver and monitor had not strapped her in properly — "causing her death."
Ngone, a second-grader at Roselawn Condon School who was nonverbal and used a wheelchair, died on the afternoon of Sept. 16, 2026, on the ride home from school. Her family found her lifeless in her wheelchair after the bus arrived at their home. The bus had sat idle outside the house for about 10 minutes, which the family said was unusual. She was rushed to Cincinnati Children's Hospital, where she was pronounced dead.
The Hamilton County Coroner's Office ruled her death accidental. An autopsy found she died from positional asphyxiation and noted a "delay in care." The report said Ngone was restrained by a five-point seatbelt system — two shoulder straps, two lap straps and one between the legs — and that during movement her buttocks slipped off the wheelchair seat, her torso turned to the right, and her neck and chin were compressed by the restraint system.
The emails were released Nov. 13, after The Cincinnati Enquirer filed a public records request. In an email sent at 8:39 p.m. on Sept. 16, just hours after Ngone died, Superintendent Shauna Murphy wrote to the school board about a conversation with the president of the bus company, First Student.
"I spoke with Mr. John Keening from First Student. He shared the driver and monitor on Ngone's bus did not strap her on appropriately, causing her death," Murphy wrote.
First Student confirmed that the conversation between its CEO and the superintendent took place on the night of Ngone's death, but disputed her account of it. "At that point, no investigation had taken place, and many facts were still unknown," the company said in a statement on Nov. 13. "The characterization of the conversation does not reflect the circumstances surrounding the incident or the findings subsequently outlined in the coroner's report."
Cincinnati Public Schools said in a statement Friday that a thorough review must take place so the district has a clear and accurate understanding of the facts. "We owe that to the family, our students, and the community. The Board will not rush to judgment or make determinations before that process is complete," the district said. The district added that Murphy's Sept. 16 message reflected the information available to the schools that evening.
On Nov. 13, Ngone's father, Abdoula Talla, told The Enquirer in a phone call that he had not been told about his daughter not being properly strapped in.
Cincinnati police continue to investigate the death, and no charges have been filed. The district said First Student removed the driver and the monitor from Ngone's bus route pending the investigation. The bus was operated by First Student, which the district contracts with to provide buses and drivers, on the roughly eight-mile route from Roselawn Condon School to the family's home in the 4200 block of Colerain Avenue in Northside.
Sources: The Cincinnati Enquirer, "Staff didn't properly strap in CPS student who died on bus, emails say" (Nov. 13, 2026, search result verified); New York Post, "Bus staff didn't properly strap in Ohio special needs student, 7, 'causing her death,' emails reveal" (Nov. 14, 2026, full text verified). Event date verified: the emails were released Nov. 13, 2026; Ngone Talla died Sept. 16, 2026.
Sponsored
